|
|
| (18 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown) |
| Line 1: |
Line 1: |
| *Orv, what about the Qel-Droma Logo??? We both made one, we need approval from Khob. --[[User:Kel Antar|Kel]] 11:08, 17 May 2007 (MDT)
| |
| *That Qel-Droma logo I uploaded has been in place since Etah was in charge. It has been the Qel-Droma logo since February 18th. --[[User:Orv Dessrx]] 13:14, 17 May 2007 (EST)
| |
|
| |
|
| * I wanted to upload mine to the database, but the Internet cut me off. This is the new Qel-Droma page so where was your logo in place earlier? I'm just uploading mine, tell me what you think. And when Khob comes and edit the history, we will ask him. Nicely. :P Remember your image name, because I'm temporarily putting in mine. --[[User:Kel Antar|Kel]] 23:36, 17 May 2007 (MDT) | | == Logo == |
| | * Develops Order, Clan, House, Family and Society symbols and logos as necessary |
| | * Responsible for safeguarding against unnecessary revision of existing logos and symbols, as they are crucial to consistent identity marking |
| | While I do not mind others running competitions for House emblems, it is the duty of the Herald to approve the application of House and/or Clan emblems. As this was not sent for approval, I request that this image be deleted, as well as the warbanner attached to this page. Grandfathering is not an excuse. Thank you. --[[User:Shikyo Keibatsu|Shikyo]] 00:02, 11 Oct 2008 (EST) |
|
| |
|
| * FYI, I'm reverting the QD image on the wiki page back to mine as it is the current official logo. If it is being changed, that needs to be run by Khob and Etah. Here are the two images:
| | Do you have another logo for HQD that this replaced? Unless there's a pre-existing and better alternative, I don't see any reason for this to be removed "just because". I don't think one existed because the House had been closed for a good long while, and existed solely as a Battleteam. As there wasn't a logo to change or replace, how would adopting this one cause problems with consistency? And really, your HRLD description says that your job is to safeguard against unnecessary change and revision, preserve consistent identity, etc, not that all images need to be approved. If that's what you want it to say, write it that way, don't imply. Oh, and nice lie btw.: |
|
| |
|
| [[image:QeldromaBattleTeam.jpg|200px]]
| | <`Shikyo> At what point did I say stop? |
| [[Image:qel-droma_kelantar1583.jpg|200px]]
| |
|
| |
|
| I like them both, although I am hesitant on the visibility of your logo's elements at smaller proportions. (i.e. the text)
| |
| --[[User:Orv Dessrx]] 07:56, 18 May 2007 (EST)
| |
|
| |
|
| * :/
| | <`Shikyo> That's the major confliction with this discussion. I never said that it should be taken down or removed. I just wished that it was brought to my attention. |
|
| |
|
| I'm waiting. Actually, the text is not something you can read, it should be "Qel" in the Hutts font but I totally changed it. And I have the same logo in white background, as well as black one. I'm feeling a bit of competitive spirit over here ah? :P --[[User:Kel Antar|Kel]] 07:24, 18 May 2007 (MDT)
| | -- [/code/index.php?title=User:Xander_Drax&action=edit&redlink=1 Xander Drax] 10:31, 11 October 2008 (MDT) |
|
| |
|
| * Competitive? ...not really. I mean, the logo I uploaded isn't of my design so I have no extreme ties to it save for the fact that I spent time on creating it in Photoshop :P The fact of the matter is, the ''current'' logo for Qel-Droma is not yours until the leadership of Galeres and Qel-Droma decide it is. If the general populous dislikes Etah's design, and yours wins out...so be it. We just can't go swapping the logo at a whim. --[[User:Orv Dessrx]] 09:43, 18 May 2007 (EST)
| | |
| | |
| | == Deletion == |
| | Can someone please delete this page? It's no longer relevant. Thanks. --[[User:Kel Antar|Kel]] 08:43, 28 May 2007 (MDT)[[File:Kelantar.PNG|35px]] |
| | |
| | Actually, Qel-Droma is also a former House of Clan Arcona that is currently closed. As such, this page should probably concern itself with the history of that House, instead of the Battleteam that was named after the closed House--[[User:Halcyon|Halcyon]] 10:32, 28 May 2007 (MDT) |
| | |
| | |
| | * So, can you change the page name to "House Qel-Droma"? Thanks. --[[User:Kel Antar|Kel]] 10:49, 28 May 2007 (MDT) [[File:Kelantar.PNG|35px]] |
| | * If this is a page on a past '''battle''' '''team''' then it shouldn't be deleted. Just because a '''team''' is no longer opened doesn't mean it has no place in history. You don't see people taking Julius Caesar out of encyclopedias just because he has been dead for hundreds of years ;) |
| | Aside from that, if the old house needs an article, which it probably does, then another one should be made, unless you'd like to use this one for both the house and battleteam. Either way, the '''battle''' '''team''' still should be known about [[User:Aabsdu|Aabs]] 15:06, 28 May 2007 (MDT) |
| | |
| | The entire page is basically about the House, except for certain specifics concerning the BT. There is no written history about the BT, as it was once a continuation of the House itself, after it was closed. So probably easier to re-name it and focus on completing that portion of the history--[[User:Halcyon|Halcyon]] 15:28, 28 May 2007 (MDT) |
| | |
| | |
| | * Ok, I have an idea, I'll just write the history of this '''Battle''' '''Team''', and how it got closed, and I will make a special page for the house Qel-Droma --[[User:Kel Antar|Kel]] 15:34, 28 May 2007 (MDT)[[File:Kelantar.PNG|35px]] |
| | * Reverted edit and changed it so it is now about House Qel-Droma. |
| | |
| | == Refocus == |
| | There is way too much fluff on the "person" Qel-Droma that should be cut out. It's completely pointless. Yes, I know the house was named after him. but we don't need his life history in a nutshell here. Link to Wookieepedia. |
| | |
| | Rename the article itself ''House Qel-Droma'', kill the first 2 sections, check for oddities in the wording (House Arcona?), straighten out what's left to make it more clear (check for spelling/grammar), fix mistakes in coding (around a mention of Gilkane there is ]] ]] instead of [[ ]] for a link) and this might actually shape up into something decent. |
Logo
- Develops Order, Clan, House, Family and Society symbols and logos as necessary
- Responsible for safeguarding against unnecessary revision of existing logos and symbols, as they are crucial to consistent identity marking
While I do not mind others running competitions for House emblems, it is the duty of the Herald to approve the application of House and/or Clan emblems. As this was not sent for approval, I request that this image be deleted, as well as the warbanner attached to this page. Grandfathering is not an excuse. Thank you. --Shikyo 00:02, 11 Oct 2008 (EST)
Do you have another logo for HQD that this replaced? Unless there's a pre-existing and better alternative, I don't see any reason for this to be removed "just because". I don't think one existed because the House had been closed for a good long while, and existed solely as a Battleteam. As there wasn't a logo to change or replace, how would adopting this one cause problems with consistency? And really, your HRLD description says that your job is to safeguard against unnecessary change and revision, preserve consistent identity, etc, not that all images need to be approved. If that's what you want it to say, write it that way, don't imply. Oh, and nice lie btw.:
<`Shikyo> At what point did I say stop?
<`Shikyo> That's the major confliction with this discussion. I never said that it should be taken down or removed. I just wished that it was brought to my attention.
-- [/code/index.php?title=User:Xander_Drax&action=edit&redlink=1 Xander Drax] 10:31, 11 October 2008 (MDT)
Deletion
Can someone please delete this page? It's no longer relevant. Thanks. --Kel 08:43, 28 May 2007 (MDT)
Actually, Qel-Droma is also a former House of Clan Arcona that is currently closed. As such, this page should probably concern itself with the history of that House, instead of the Battleteam that was named after the closed House--Halcyon 10:32, 28 May 2007 (MDT)
- So, can you change the page name to "House Qel-Droma"? Thanks. --Kel 10:49, 28 May 2007 (MDT)
- If this is a page on a past battle team then it shouldn't be deleted. Just because a team is no longer opened doesn't mean it has no place in history. You don't see people taking Julius Caesar out of encyclopedias just because he has been dead for hundreds of years ;)
Aside from that, if the old house needs an article, which it probably does, then another one should be made, unless you'd like to use this one for both the house and battleteam. Either way, the battle team still should be known about Aabs 15:06, 28 May 2007 (MDT)
The entire page is basically about the House, except for certain specifics concerning the BT. There is no written history about the BT, as it was once a continuation of the House itself, after it was closed. So probably easier to re-name it and focus on completing that portion of the history--Halcyon 15:28, 28 May 2007 (MDT)
- Ok, I have an idea, I'll just write the history of this Battle Team, and how it got closed, and I will make a special page for the house Qel-Droma --Kel 15:34, 28 May 2007 (MDT)
- Reverted edit and changed it so it is now about House Qel-Droma.
Refocus
There is way too much fluff on the "person" Qel-Droma that should be cut out. It's completely pointless. Yes, I know the house was named after him. but we don't need his life history in a nutshell here. Link to Wookieepedia.
Rename the article itself House Qel-Droma, kill the first 2 sections, check for oddities in the wording (House Arcona?), straighten out what's left to make it more clear (check for spelling/grammar), fix mistakes in coding (around a mention of Gilkane there is ]] ]] instead of [[ ]] for a link) and this might actually shape up into something decent.